Phone Order Credit Card Fraud: A Warning for NL Businesses

By August 17, 2026Commercial Insurance
Credit card being hooked by a phishing fishhook on a laptop keyboard, symbolizing credit card fraud
Home » Blog » Phone Order Credit Card Fraud: A Warning for NL Businesses
If you run a retail or wholesale business in Newfoundland and Labrador and you take orders over the phone, there’s a scam you need to know about. We’ve heard from a few local business owners recently who got hit by the same trick, and it’s costing them real money.
Here’s how it plays out.

How the Scam Works

A customer calls in about a product you carry. Nothing unusual so far. Then they say something like, “I can’t find these anywhere else; I’d like to buy all the stock you have.” It sounds like a dream order. One recent case involved a large quantity of, let’s say, generators, but the product doesn’t matter much; it’s whatever a business happens to have a lot of on hand.
The customer pays over the phone with a credit card, and the payment goes through. It’s approved; it looks completely normal on your end. A shipping company then arrives to pick up the order, often one the customer arranged rather than your usual carrier.
Then, days later, you get an email from your payment processor: fraud detected on this transaction. The card was stolen. The charge gets reversed. And the product, along with the shipping company that picked it up, is long gone.

Infographic explaining a phone order credit card fraud scam: buyer calls wanting to buy all stock, card is approved, their own shipper picks up the order, and days later the charge reverses as fraud

Why This Works So Well

The frustrating part is that everything looked legitimate in the moment. The card was approved at the time of sale. That’s because phone orders are what’s called “card-not-present” transactions, and the fraud detection on the card issuer’s side often doesn’t catch it until after the transaction settles, sometimes days later.
Under standard card network rules, the liability for card-not-present fraud typically falls on the merchant, not the bank or the cardholder. So the business is left having shipped real product and lost the payment, both at once.
Scammers count on urgency and flattery to keep you from slowing down and asking the questions you normally would.

Red Flags to Watch For

A few patterns show up again and again in these calls:
  • The order is unusually large, especially “I want everything you have,” rather than a specific quantity.
  • The buyer pushes for speed, wanting the order paid and shipped right away.
  • The buyer arranges their own shipping company or freight pickup instead of using your normal delivery process.
  • The shipping address doesn’t match the billing address on the card.
  • You can’t easily verify who the buyer is or find them anywhere online.
  • The buyer is happy to pay full price without any negotiation, which is unusual for a bulk order.
If a call checks two or three of these boxes, it’s worth pausing before you process anything.

What To Do If a Call Feels Off

Before shipping a large phone order, a few extra steps can save you a lot of grief:
  • Call the number on the back of the card, not a number the caller gives you, to verify the cardholder.
  • Ask for photo ID or a callback number and actually use it.
  • Consider holding large phone orders until the transaction has fully settled, rather than shipping same day.
  • Set an internal threshold where any phone order above a certain dollar amount gets a second look before it ships
  • Trust your gut. If something about the urgency or the story feels off, it’s fine to slow the process down or decline.

If It’s Already Happened to You

If you’ve already shipped an order and gotten the fraud notice, here’s where to start:
  • Document everything you have: caller ID, correspondence, shipping records, the fraud notice itself.
  • Contact your payment processor or bank right away to understand your options.
  • File a report with your local police and with the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre.
  • Take a look at your commercial insurance policy. Standard property coverage often doesn’t cover this kind of loss, but some businesses have crime or fraud endorsements that might help, depending on the circumstances.
That last point is worth a conversation with your broker rather than guessing. If you’re not sure what your current policy covers for this kind of situation, our team at Wedgwood is happy to take a look with you, no pressure, so that you know where you stand before it happens rather than after.
Scams like this tend to spread quickly once word gets out that they’re working. If you’ve seen something similar at your business, it’s worth giving your staff a heads-up too.

LET'S TALK COVERAGE

Get coverage for your business, home, and car—with advice you can trust.

Call

About Wedgwood Insurance

Wedgwood Insurance has offices in St. John’s & Corner Brook and is Newfoundland & Labrador’s largest independent insurance broker. We provide straightforward home, auto & business insurance advice.

With over 400+ Google My Business reviews, experience the Wedgwood difference with expert advice from our dedicated team. We ensure that every client has the coverage that best suits their needs through upfront complimentary consultations and midterm reviews.

Contact Us

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Author Jamie Ross

Jamie Ross leads the Marketing and Communications team at Wedgwood Insurance, renowned as one of Atlantic Canada’s premier independent insurance brokers. Bringing a wealth of experience amassed over many years at some of Canada's most esteemed advertising agencies, Jamie transitioned to the insurance industry in 2017. This pivotal move has marked a period of significant professional growth and contribution to the field. A native Nova Scotian, Jamie has been a resident of St. John's, NL, since 2011, where he has become an integral part of the local community. Learn more about Jamie.

More posts by Jamie Ross