
If you rent out a property in St. John’s, Corner Brook, or anywhere else in the province, your homeowners policy probably isn’t doing what you think it’s doing. Most standard home insurance is written for owner-occupied homes. The moment you hand someone else the keys and start collecting rent, you’ve changed the risk, and most insurers will tell you the same thing: that policy no longer applies the way you’d expect.
That’s where landlord insurance comes in. Here’s what it covers, why it matters more here than elsewhere, and what to watch for as a property owner in NL.
What is landlord insurance?
Landlord insurance, sometimes called rental property insurance, is built specifically for properties you own but don’t live in. It covers the building itself, protects you if someone gets hurt on the property, and can replace rental income if a covered loss makes the place unlivable. A standard homeowners policy typically won’t cover that.
It’s different from tenant insurance too. Your tenant’s insurance protects their belongings and their liability. Yours protects the building, your liability as the owner, and your income from the property. You need both, and they’re not interchangeable.
What it typically covers
Every policy looks a little different, and coverage depends on the property and how it’s used, but landlord insurance generally includes:
- The building itself: fire, wind, water damage, and other named perils, plus anything permanently attached, like built-in appliances or flooring you installed
- Liability protection: if a tenant or visitor is injured on the property and you’re found responsible
- Loss of rental income: if the unit becomes uninhabitable after a covered event and you can’t collect rent while it’s being repaired
- Optional extras: things like vandalism by tenants, equipment breakdown, or coverage for a secondary suite, depending on your provider
It usually won’t cover your tenant’s belongings. That’s on them, which is exactly why more landlords are requiring proof of tenant insurance as a condition of the lease.
Why it matters more here in NL
A few things make landlord insurance a bigger deal in this province than elsewhere.
Our housing stock is older. Many rental properties in NL, especially in St. John’s, are older homes converted into apartments or basement suites over the years. Older wiring, older roofs, and older plumbing all raise the odds of a claim, and insurers price that in.
Oil heat is still common. Plenty of homes here still run on oil furnaces with above-ground or buried tanks, and a leaking tank is one of the more expensive claims an insurer can see. If you’re renting out a property with an oil tank, expect your insurer to ask about its age and condition, and expect it to affect your premium.
And the weather doesn’t do us any favours. Wind, ice damming, and water damage are consistently among the most common claims in this province. A rental property sitting through a January storm needs the same protection as any home, but with a tenant living in it and rent riding on the outcome, the stakes are higher if something goes wrong.
Mistakes we see landlords make
The most common one is simple: not telling the insurer the property is rented. If you convert a home you used to live in into a rental and don’t update your policy, you could find out the hard way, at claim time, that you’re not covered the way you assumed.
The second is assuming a vacant or unoccupied policy is close enough. It isn’t. Vacant home coverage and landlord coverage solve different problems.
And the third is skipping loss of rental income coverage to save a few dollars a month. If a pipe bursts and your tenant has to move out for six weeks while repairs happen, that’s six weeks of rent you’re not collecting, on top of the repair bill, unless that piece is in place.
Getting the right coverage
A few things worth doing before you renew or take out a new policy.
Talk to someone who knows the local risk. A broker who understands NL weather, older housing stock, and how oil heat factors into a policy will ask better questions than a national call centre would.
Require proof of tenant insurance in your lease. It protects your tenant’s belongings and lowers the odds that a dispute over damaged property lands on your desk.
Review your coverage as things change. Rents go up, property values go up, and a policy you set up five years ago might not reflect what it would actually cost to rebuild the property or replace lost income today.
We’re here if you want a second look
If you own a rental property in NL and aren’t sure your current policy covers you the way you think it does, that’s a quick conversation, not a big project. Reach out to our team, and we’ll walk through what you’ve got and where the gaps might be.
LET'S TALK COVERAGE
Get coverage for your business, home, and car—with advice you can trust.
About Wedgwood Insurance
Wedgwood Insurance has offices in St. John’s & Corner Brook and is Newfoundland & Labrador’s largest independent insurance broker. We provide straightforward home, auto & business insurance advice.
With over 450 Google My Business reviews, experience the Wedgwood difference with expert advice from our dedicated team. We ensure that every client has the coverage that best suits their needs through upfront complimentary consultations and midterm reviews.
Contact Us




